By -

Late in May, I put together a post called The DMC Challenge in which I put together two hypothetical portfolios: one had nothing but my favorite short ideas, and another had nothing but my favorite long ideas.

It’s been quite interesting to watch. As of today, the short portfolio had suffered a hit of about 8.1%. However, the long portfolio was up 25%. In other words, in the face of this ascending market, my long ideas outperformed my short ideas 3-to-1. One could have taken positions in every single long and short idea and still be ahead by about 17% over the past five weeks or so.

Here are the top three worst performers in the short portfolio (for instance, NLS has gone up 64%, which would be very bad for a short position):

  • NLS 64%
  • LAD 33%
  • OI 33%

And here are the three best shorts.

  • VLO 13%
  • CRUS 16%
  • PSXP 24%

As for the all long portfolio, here are the three worst ones. Indeed, out of the whole portfolio, only two of them had a loss at all.

  • AUDC down 12%
  • INTC down 4.8%
  • MDB up 2.5%

Whereas the three top long gainers were……….

  • VAPO up 63.8%
  • BLDP up 95.1%
  • PLUG up 141.8%

Here is a chart of the short sale champ:

slopechart PSXP

And, with a triple-digit return, here’s the long position champ:

slopechart PLUG

What’s the takeaway from all this? Well, I think it shows how effective technical analysis can be, because although my shorts suffered, my long ideas more than made up for it, even when we had no idea what was going to happen over the next five weeks.